Niacinamide and Skin Exfoliation: A Shocking Truth
Date: September 13, 2023 Categories: Knowledge、Q&A Views: 619
I’m pretty sure that anyone who has ever been a fan of niacinamide, especially for its whitening benefits, will have a completely new perspective on skincare after reading this article. Of course, this process also means that your old beliefs will be shattered. So, fair warning: this might not be a comfortable experience. Those who have had their worldview challenged before will understand...
For such an extraordinary article, I’ve decided to change the narrative order and start with the conclusion: Niacinamide can exfoliate the skin! And its effectiveness is comparable to that of AHAs (alpha hydroxy acids)!
Don't doubt your eyes or your understanding. When I say exfoliation, I mean "chemical exfoliation," which is often used to describe the effects of AHAs. In other words, niacinamide and AHAs work similarly in terms of whitening. They both accelerate the shedding of the stratum corneum, promote epidermal renewal, and reduce melanin deposition, thereby achieving a whitening effect.
However, the most reliable scientific explanations you can find now describe niacinamide's whitening mechanism as inhibiting the transfer of melanin from melanocytes to keratinocytes.
So, what's going on?
Could it be that this seemingly profound theory, widely propagated by many experts, is flawed? It can't possibly be related to "chemical exfoliation," can it?
Well, once you understand the origins of this theory, everything will become clear.
First of all, do you know who conducted the original research that popularized this theory of niacinamide's whitening mechanism in the beauty industry?
The answer is: Procter & Gamble.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to say there's anything fishy about P&G's research. On the contrary, as a cosmetics company, I think they've done a pretty good job. The study involved seven experiments, five in vitro and two in vivo, and the data analysis was quite detailed. It was also published in a reputable journal.
However, the authors of the popular science articles you've read may not have carefully examined this study or delved deeper into the detailed evidence supporting their conclusions.
Yes, I dug deeper into the original source of this conclusion, a 2002 article published in the British Journal of Dermatology titled "The effect of niacinamide on reducing cutaneous pigmentation and suppression of melanosome transfer." This is a research paper published in a medical journal, combining both in vitro experiments commonly used in the cosmetics industry and more challenging in vivo experiments. Although it was produced by P&G, in my opinion, it represents the most reliable method for demonstrating the efficacy of a skincare ingredient. So, I read it carefully.
The gist of the article is this:
Two in vivo experiments confirmed that niacinamide had a visible whitening effect. To understand the mechanism behind this effect, a series of in vitro experiments were conducted.
First, three in vitro experiments demonstrated that niacinamide had no significant effect on tyrosinase activity or melanin synthesis, which are two key factors in skin whitening. These in vitro experiments are commonly used in the cosmetics industry to screen whitening agents. Well-known whitening agents like arbutin, 377, vitamin C, and kojic acid excel in one or more of these experiments. However, niacinamide failed to show any significant effect in any of them! It's quite odd. So, what to do? Keep experimenting.
Two other in vitro experiments were conducted, which I had never seen before. The main goal was to study the interaction between keratinocytes and melanocytes during the melanin transfer process.
One experiment was conducted in culture media containing both keratinocytes and melanocytes. The results showed that:
- When only keratinocytes were present, no melanin was expressed.
- When both keratinocytes and melanocytes were present, a large amount of melanin was expressed.
- When keratinocytes, melanocytes, and niacinamide were co-cultured, melanin expression was significantly lower compared to the second condition. However, the experiment used two different groups of keratinocytes, and the results varied significantly, with the reason not mentioned in the literature.
Another experiment was closer to a real-world scenario, conducted on a pigmented skin model (an artificial skin with pigmentation used for experiments). The results were also promising, showing that the pigmentation was significantly reduced in the samples treated with niacinamide.
Based on these findings, the conclusion was drawn that niacinamide can inhibit the transfer of melanin from melanocytes to keratinocytes.
However, after reading the entire article, I couldn't help but feel that something was missing. It was difficult to fully convince me...
For example, in the in vitro experiment, it could only suggest that the whitening effect of niacinamide might occur during the transfer of melanin from melanocytes to keratinocytes. Please note the word "might," as the actual in vivo environment is very complex and quite different from culturing two groups of cells in a petri dish. Moreover, this experiment could not explain exactly which step in the melanin transfer process was inhibited. This process may sound simple, but it's actually very complex.
And what about the experiment on the artificial pigmented skin? Although it was closer to a real-world scenario, it couldn't be used to prove that niacinamide's effect definitely occurred during the transfer of melanin from melanocytes to keratinocytes. Could it be that the reduction in pigmentation was due to accelerated keratinocyte turnover? This is exactly how AHAs work... (I hadn't thought of this at the time, but I knew there was a big gap between in vitro experiments and actual effects, so I didn't fully believe in niacinamide's whitening effect. I even thought it was just good marketing by P&G.)
Sure enough, in another similar study supported by P&G in 2004, I found a similar description of the limitations of the in vitro experiment:
"Niacinamide was observed to inhibit the transfer of melanin from melanocytes to keratinocytes. However, this process involves many steps, and the specific step at which niacinamide acts remains to be elucidated."
As for the doubt about the artificial pigmented skin experiment, I discovered it by chance later on.
One day, my teacher assigned me a task: to write a review on niacinamide. So, of course, I started searching for information everywhere. As a result, I accidentally came across this passage:
This was published in the Journal of Cosmetic and Laser Therapy in 2006, and it mainly discussed the oil-control function of niacinamide. The speculation about the mechanism of niacinamide's oil control was that it was related to promoting keratinocyte exfoliation! (Many people have reported that their skin produces less oil after using AHAs, but I've always been puzzled by this. Most literature doesn't explain it, and some don't even mention this function. This passage provided a new perspective.)
Seriously? When I first saw this passage, I had this expression:
Niacinamide can also exfoliate???!!!
I even thought I had read it wrong. I read the entire paragraph over and over again to confirm that it was correct and that the conclusion was also supported by references.
So, could this conclusion be unreliable?
I quickly went to the end and found the corresponding reference, "Moisturizing effects of topical nicotinamide on atopic dry skin." I downloaded it and searched. However, from beginning to end, it only talked about the moisturizing effect of niacinamide and didn't mention exfoliation at all.
Damn, was I really wrong?
I wasn't convinced and continued to dig. However, no matter how I changed the keywords to search for related content on niacinamide exfoliation in the database, it was like a stone sinking into the sea, with no response... Things seemed to have reached a dead end.
Until one day, out of desperation, I downloaded a review article that looked completely unappealing... You know, these review articles, the titles can be so boring. By that time, I had read so many niacinamide reviews that I had completely lost interest. But because I have a habit of collecting materials, regardless of whether they are valuable or interesting, I would download any professionally related content that I came across. (Actually, it's because English literature is so difficult to download, and I didn't want to miss out on anything today, haha.)
As a result, this boring review article that I almost missed completely solved my doubts!
This review finally mentioned again that niacinamide can exfoliate! And it provided the source literature and described the experimental method. Coincidentally, the method was the dansyl chloride fluorescence labeling experiment that I was most familiar with! This is a widely used experiment to detect the renewal rate of epidermal cells (you can think of this experiment as a more direct way to test whether a certain ingredient has an exfoliating effect). That's right, it was it!
Thanks to CCTV, thanks to MV, and thanks to my bad habit of downloading too many articles, haha!
Unfortunately, the source of this experiment on niacinamide is the 58th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Dermatology. No matter how hard I tried, I couldn't download it... But the title was accurate: "New facial moisturizer technology increases exfoliation without compromising barrier function." If anyone has access to it, please share it with everyone!
Since I couldn't find the original article, I decided to conduct the experiment myself.
To make it more relatable (and useful for everyone), I didn't prepare a new product. I directly compared The Ordinary Niacinamide (claimed to contain 10% niacinamide) and Cetaphil Restoraderm Skin Restoring Moisturizer (claimed to contain 10% AHAs)!(In China, the maximum allowed concentration of AHAs is 6%, so I don't know if the imported Cetaphil product has adjusted the formula.)
The results showed that The Ordinary Niacinamide and Cetaphil Restoraderm had similar effects, and niacinamide even performed slightly better!
I have the pictures to prove it!
The experiment was conducted on the inner forearms of three people (two women and one man, with an average age of 34) for three times (almost a month for each person). Each person had to go through a skin pre-treatment process, applying the products every day until the skin adapted. Only then could the staining begin, and the experiment officially started! Then, we had to take photos. The later it got, the harder it was to take photos because the fluorescence became weaker and the contrast became weaker. Sometimes, I had to hold the camera and the Wood's lamp and pose for a long time...
Actually, the most painful part was the pre-experiment. It took half a year and countless trials because I encountered so many problems. Seriously, human experiments seem simple, but they are actually the most difficult. There are too many influencing factors, and each problem needs to be solved one by one by consulting literature and modifying the experimental plan. By the way, whenever my family saw me with these things, they were scared because I might be staining and applying something on them again...
Although the sample size of this experiment is still too small and it's far from being published in certain journals, I think it's enough to provide a reference for your daily skincare routine!
In fact, I also conducted a comparative experiment on my own face. The result was that using a dime-sized amount of The Ordinary Niacinamide once a day perfectly controlled my occasional breakouts, just like Cetaphil Restoraderm! I didn't expect this before I learned about this secret about niacinamide. I bought The Ordinary purely to see what the texture was like, and I didn't expect it to have any effect, especially since it had a terrible smell, was prone to pilling, and was slightly irritating...
However, it seems that if I consistently use Cetaphil, my stratum corneum becomes more transparent and uniform, my pores become finer, and my skin has a higher luster. When I take pictures with others, I can see that my skin reflects light more than others, not the oily kind of reflection (I have very little oil production), but just a pure glow. Of course, this experiment is not very rigorous, and there are no comparison photos. Moreover, I stopped using it for four or five days recently, and my acne hasn't recurred (my acne used to recur if I stopped using Cetaphil for a week). I'm starting to wonder if I've completely escaped the curse of acne, haha! In any case, this experience is for reference only, and I will provide updates if I have new findings.









