Niacinamide: What You Need to Know

Date: September 13, 2023 Categories: Knowledge、Q&A Views: 544

What exactly does niacinamide do?

Sorry, but I’m going to dive into some science here.

"Niacinamide" might sound like a complicated term, but it’s actually a derivative of vitamin B3, also known as vitamin PP. So when you see brands promoting "cellular-level B3 repair factors," now you know why marketing departments exist—you get it…

Niacinamide is produced from β-methylpyridine, which is oxidized in air to form niacin. The latter reacts with ammonium hydroxide and is dehydrated through heating. The quality of niacinamide depends on its niacin content; if the niacin concentration reaches a certain level, it can harm the skin barrier.

Niacinamide is indeed recognized as a beneficial ingredient in skincare, and I’ll break it down into three key areas:

  1. Barrier Repair: If a skincare product contains niacinamide, you’ll often see claims about repairing the skin barrier, enhancing the skin’s protection against external damage.
  2. Brightening: At a concentration of around 2%, niacinamide can inhibit melanin production, often referred to as brightening the skin tone.
  3. Antioxidant Effects: When niacinamide concentration reaches 5%, it theoretically provides antioxidant benefits, which translates into claims about preventing skin aging.

In summary, when niacinamide is included in skincare products, you’ll often see promotional phrases like:

  • Whitening and reducing pigmentation
  • Oil control and acne suppression
  • Anti-aging and improving fine lines
  • Repairing and enhancing skin barrier function

However, not every ingredient works for everyone.

Some may think niacinamide is perfect after this analysis! Some might even say, "The higher the concentration, the better—let’s buy it!"

Here, I remind everyone to approach science rationally. There’s no consensus in academia that higher concentrations are always better. There’s also a saying that "a drug can be toxic."

Mechanism of Niacinamide for Skin Whitening

There are over 40 mechanisms involved in skin whitening, but niacinamide primarily works through two:

  1. Inhibition of Melanin Transfer: Melanin is produced in melanocytes deep within the skin. Once produced, it’s transported to surrounding keratinocytes. Niacinamide can interfere with this transport, keeping melanin in the melanocytes, preventing further production, and stopping it from reaching the skin surface, thus achieving a whitening effect. This process was confirmed in 2005 by a collaborative study from Procter & Gamble's Japan and U.S. teams published in ED, demonstrating that niacinamide inhibits melanin transfer in a reversible manner.
  2. Anti-Glycation Effects: Niacinamide has been shown to effectively prevent yellowing of the skin. This effect may involve its antioxidant mechanisms through NAD(P)H, particularly in stopping protein glycation (Maillard reaction). The end products of glycation are cross-linked brown-yellow proteins (Amadori products) that accumulate in the skin. Niacinamide has been reported to possess anti-glycation properties.

Some might believe that the "re-darkening" phenomenon after stopping niacinamide is due to "dependency," but niacinamide is not a hormone, so there’s no such dependency. However, there’s no one-size-fits-all whitening solution; scientists are being truthful about this.

Mechanism of Niacinamide for Spot Reduction

A study published in the Chinese Medical Aesthetic Journal in November 2019 discussed how niacinamide can help treat melasma through its anti-inflammatory properties. Research shows that the onset of melasma is related to inflammation and capillary dilation in the affected areas. In skin with melasma, TLR-2 and TLR-4 mRNA levels were significantly higher than in healthy controls, indicating that skin inflammation contributes to melasma. Niacinamide’s anti-inflammatory effects significantly inhibit inflammation-induced pigmentation mediated by TLR-2 or TLR-4, with this effect correlating positively with its concentration.

Scientists conducted a randomized, double-blind clinical trial with 2,527 melasma patients over 8 weeks, comparing 4% niacinamide cream to 4% hydroquinone cream (currently banned in cosmetics but undetectable by testing methods). Both treatments showed significant effects: 44% of patients using niacinamide experienced noticeable improvement, compared to 55% using hydroquinone. Additionally, 18% of niacinamide users reported side effects, while 29% of hydroquinone users did, indicating that niacinamide has fewer side effects and is safer than hydroquinone.

Anti-Aging and Fine Line Improvement (Antioxidant)

Different ingredients approach the theme of "anti-aging" in various ways. For niacinamide, it’s through its antioxidant properties.

However, niacinamide’s "antioxidant" effect doesn’t involve directly fighting free radicals like vitamin C. Instead, niacinamide serves as a precursor for NAD/NADP in the body. Research indicates that using niacinamide increases the reduced form of NADPH in the skin, subsequently enhancing the synthesis speed and quantity of various skin components, from keratin to collagen.

Repairing Skin Barrier Function

Scientists have researched how niacinamide repairs skin barrier function, focusing on two main aspects:

  • Promotes Ceramide Synthesis: Niacinamide enhances the activity of rate-limiting enzymes involved in ceramide synthesis, improving the speed and efficiency of the process.
  • Accelerates Keratinocyte Differentiation: When NADP levels are low in the skin, signs of aging appear, including slower renewal and dullness, leading to weakened protective functions.

Thus, niacinamide enhances antioxidant characteristics by increasing NADP, speeding up keratinocyte differentiation, and promoting keratin metabolism, restoring compromised skin protection.

Studies have shown that niacinamide can effectively reduce moisture loss and improve resistance to external stimuli.

Research on the Irritancy of Niacinamide

There’s a lot of debate around the irritancy and other indicators of niacinamide. Nowadays, products with concentrations of 2%, 5%, and 10% niacinamide are flooding the market. Let’s conduct an irritancy test on this ingredient.

Irritancy Evaluation – CAMVA Test

Basic Principle:

The CAM (Chick Embryo Chorioallantoic Membrane) test utilizes the vascular system of a fertilized chicken embryo, which is around 10 to 14 days old. This test takes advantage of the complete, clear, and transparent characteristics of the CAM’s vascular system. We directly apply a certain amount of the test substance to the CAM, observe vascular damage after a set time, and score the severity of the damage. The more severe the damage, the higher the score. This method particularly emphasizes detecting vascular effects, such as shadow vessels, capillary congestion, and capillary bleeding.

Scoring Criteria:

We tested water solutions of niacinamide at concentrations of 2%, 5%, and 10%. The data is summarized in the table below:

Display of the chicken embryo results after testing.

From the results, we can see that as the concentration of niacinamide increases, the level of irritation rises sharply. At a concentration of 10%, irreversible damage was already evident.

Many products on the market boast high niacinamide concentrations, leading consumers to believe that higher is better. This is a typical marketing tactic, and I’ll clarify this with science.

Summary

Through this article, I’ve unveiled the "mystery" of niacinamide, concluding as follows:

  • Stopping niacinamide for whitening may lead to "re-darkening."
  • The process of niacinamide inhibiting melanin transfer is reversible, meaning discontinuation can cause re-darkening. For long-lasting "radiant skin," consistent use is necessary.
  • Niacinamide has effective spot-reducing benefits, but nearly 20% of users may experience side effects.
  • Higher concentrations of niacinamide increase irritancy, and at certain levels, the irritancy rises exponentially.

Overall, niacinamide is a widely used and effective skincare ingredient that offers benefits in whitening, repairing, and anti-aging. While it may not be the strongest option in each category, it performs well overall and is considered a good ingredient.

Additionally, at certain usage levels, niacinamide is relatively gentle and pairs well with other products. It doesn’t require strict timing for application, making it particularly suitable for those who prefer a low-maintenance routine.

However, be cautious not to combine it with acids during use.

FacebookXRedditPinterestLinkedIn